The Personality Pie

The inconsistency in expected behavior potentially creates dissonance in relationships. People tend to question the integrity of a relationship or an anticipated bond based on their belief in ‘knowing’ someone or how well they can ‘read’ someone. Oftentimes expectations undergo modifications until one is satisfied that he/she ‘knows’ someone. The ability to measure behavior accurately is what creates a reliable sense of rapport or camaraderie in general interactions. But what happens when expectations (what is believed) do not stack up? Well, that’s normally when someone will posit ‘oh! that’s not like him/her,’ ‘that’s not the John ‘I know,” and/or ‘I can’t believe he/she would do that,’ creating a feeling of disconnection or the unknown.

Ruminate on this – someone who grew up in a conservative household is influenced by fairly conservative social groups and generally sheltered from extreme societal customs, why should that person be anything but a product of their environment? In math, we learn 1 plus 1 equals 2, surely when you add up similar factors in someone’s living experiences their behavior should be predictable

One factor that secures the mental image of people from our interactions are our biases. By definition, Biases are intrinsic impulses that affect our perception and understand of people, events and ideas (Psychologytoday, 2020). They aren’t positive or negative but can be defined if contextualized. Because of this, we are intuitive in making quick judgment calls while crafting perspectives. This skewers expectations and builds confidence for the ‘I know’ that quickly follows… simply put, our involuntary and inevitable biases are sometimes what form the expectations we have of others.

The source of this conundrum is the complexity of personality. The problem is personality is not a singular idea and things like biases and other psychological phenomena like self-fulfilling prophecy hinder true objective examinations. People are extraordinarily layered and complex creatures. It is hard to imagine anyone is any one thing, after all – you are what you eat, you’re the sum total of top the 5 people you spend time with, you are your parent’s child, you are a reflection of societies values, norms and customs, you are the housing unit of constant chemical reactions and you are the things you identify with. All these prevailing factors become astronomically consequential when it boils down to decisions and actions that may not line up with what people believe they ‘know.’
In reality, no one confines to a single set of ideas and behavioral patterns. Personality is the product of various influences and subjectivity to inherited choices – what influences decisions/actions cannot be simplified by any one thing. Here’s the punchline, personalities are like Assorted Pies (The Big 5), you can be Open, Concessneious, Extrovert, Agreeable and Neurotic-
While each slice is a different trait, decisions made may reflect multiple slices or one dominant slice. This does not suggest that people are limited to a one-factor trait, rather, they embody an abstruse amount of potential than what we confine them to, therefore, sometimes when ‘we know’ someone, we’re not even close. It is this truth that would explain why ‘people act out things they don’t fully understand, which makes a person more complicated than their awareness of, therefore behavior sits on more information that isn’t entirely apparent to the individual ‘(P. Jordan, 2017). In this vain people are walking contradictions, not because we’re hypocritical, but because the complicity of personality is harder to command than the truth in the claims we make, and because of this people strive to represent what they believe through the variability of their personality. Hence, you be can be pro-health and indulge in fast foods, a pacifist who may know the art of war, or pious, struggling with habits that do not compliment your beliefs.

And that’s something to think about…

To make this make sense if nothing else stuck, one thing you should glean is that expectations and ideals can be insufficient in properly maximizing the examination of behavior. While some people check all the boxes and leave no room for surprises not everyone can fit our reservations. So next time, slow down if you’re about to make the claim “I know” this person because when you build up expectations that are not fulfilled, the inconsistency in expected behavior potentially creates dissonance in relationships.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *